Austria Now News

German Constitutional Court Rejects Cable Providers' Lawsuits Against Landlords' Right to Cancel Collective TV Contracts

This article was translated from Arabic. Read the Arabic original

Austria Now News – Karlsruhe

Three cable network operators in Germany have lost their lawsuits before the Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht) against a statutory special cancellation right granted to landlords for collective TV contracts following the abolition of the so-called “operating cost privilege” (Nebenkostenprivileg). The court’s First Senate rejected the constitutional complaints.

What Did the Court Say?

Court President Stephan Harbarth stated that the legislature had not exceeded the constitutional limits of its margin of discretion, despite describing the overall burden on network operators as “considerable in total.” The complaining companies—Willytel from Hamburg and Bavarian firms Rehnig Breitbandnetze & Kabelfernsehen GmbH and Ziegelmeier GmbH—argued that they alone bore the entire burden of the privilege’s abolition, violating their property rights and freedom to exercise a profession.

What is the Operating Cost Privilege?

Previously, landlords concluded collective TV contracts and passed the costs on to tenants via operating cost bills, regardless of whether the tenant wanted the subscription or not. This affected more than 12 million tenancy agreements in Germany. Tenants who preferred online streaming services were still forced to pay the traditional cable fees.

With the abolition of this privilege two years ago, landlords were allowed to terminate their collective contracts with TV providers without notice as of July 1, 2024, without providers being entitled to claim compensation—a step taken by most landlords.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Tenants?

The current situation remains unchanged: TV costs may not be passed on to tenants through operating expenses, and each tenant chooses their own method of TV reception. Decisions of the Constitutional Court are final.

Austria Now News – Keeping you updated.

Photo: Asmodea Oaktree / Wikimedia Commons – CC BY 4.0


Sources