Bundestag experts: Rwanda deportation center plan faces legal hurdles and may require Bundestag approval
This article was translated from Arabic. Read the Arabic original
Austria Now News, Berlin: Legal experts in the German Bundestag have concluded that the German government’s plan to transfer some rejected asylum seekers to a deportation center in Rwanda faces significant legal obstacles and may require approval from the Bundestag, according to a legal assessment prepared by the parliament’s Scientific Services, as reported by the newspaper Handelsblatt.
What does the legal assessment say?
The 19-page assessment was issued by the European and International Law division of the parliament’s Scientific Services (Wissenschaftliche Dienste des Bundestages). The authors believe that the new EU Return Regulation alone may not be a sufficient legal basis for these centers, and that a national legal basis does not automatically become unnecessary, as Germany remains bound by national constitutional requirements.
The experts point out that deportation to a third country may affect fundamental rights, such as personal liberty, family life, and the right to access courts. According to the assessment, the more significant a decision is for fundamental rights, the more precisely it must be regulated by the legislature itself. In their view, a non-binding declaration of intent with Rwanda is not sufficient; rather, it is more likely that an international treaty is needed, which could require the approval of parliament.
Open questions regarding the rights of deportees
The assessment notes that the EU regulation does not contain detailed rules regarding the residence status of persons deported to Rwanda, nor regarding their right to work, medical care, or freedom of movement. The Scientific Services had expressed similar reservations in a more extensive 69-page assessment in October.
Background of the plan
Germany, Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands, and Greece announced early this week that they want to transfer the first rejected asylum seekers to a return center in Rwanda within the coming year. German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt said upon the announcement that the legal framework for these return centers had been established at the EU level.
It is noted that assessments by the parliament’s Scientific Services are not legally binding, but they are considered an important reference for members of parliament in discussions about laws and agreements. So far, no new parliamentary or government decision has been made regarding the legal form of the agreement with Rwanda.
Austria Now News, we keep you updated with all the latest.
Image: Reichstag building in Berlin, Tobiasi0 via Wikimedia Commons, license CC BY-SA 4.0
Sources
n-tv: Muss Parlament zustimmen?: Bundestagsjuristen sehen rechtliche Hürden bei Abschiebezentren in Ruanda, dated 21.11.2026, Link