Austria Now News

Administrative Court in Dresden: Germany's border controls with Poland and the Czech Republic were illegal in two cases – ruling not final

This article was translated from Arabic. Read the Arabic original

Austria Now News – Dresden

The Administrative Court in Dresden (Verwaltungsgericht Dresden) has ruled in two separate proceedings that the internal border controls ordered by the Federal Ministry of the Interior (Bundesministerium des Innern) on Germany’s borders with the Czech Republic and Poland were illegal at the time they were carried out, as announced by the court on Thursday, November 12, 2026.

Who are the plaintiffs?

The first lawsuit was filed by a man from Görlitz who crosses the German-Polish border almost daily because his family lives in both parts of the divided border town. He specifically objected to his identity being checked upon entering Germany in September 2024.

The second lawsuit was brought by a German citizen from Brandenburg who was checked on May 18, 2026, inside a long-distance bus at the German-Czech border while returning from Prague, during which the Federal Police (Bundespolizei) inspected the identity documents of all passengers. According to the court, the man regularly travels to the Czech Republic to visit friends and for other purposes.

Government stance and court decision

In both cases, the Ministry of the Interior had extended the previously existing border controls by six months at a time. The federal government considered the lawsuits inadmissible, justifying the controls by citing the curbing of irregular migration and the protection of public order and internal security, pointing out that the likelihood of the plaintiffs facing renewed checks was low because the controls are carried out flexibly depending on the situation in terms of time and location.

However, the court accepted the lawsuits, finding that a repetition of the checks in both cases was not a remote possibility, and ruled that the controls were unlawful at that time.

Ruling is not final

Due to the fundamental importance of the legal issue, the court granted leave to appeal to the Higher Administrative Court of the State of Saxony (Sächsisches Oberverwaltungsgericht). At this stage, the ruling does not mean a halt to current border controls, as it relates to the two specific cases and the period during which the checks took place.

Germany implements temporary internal border controls within the Schengen area and regularly extends them, which the government describes as a tool to counter irregular migration and human smuggling.

Austria Now News – Bringing you all the latest updates.

Photo: Border checkpoint on the A3 motorway near Passau (archival image) – Raimond Spekking / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0


Sources