Federal Administrative Court in Germany rules in favour of former mayor paid less than male predecessor and successor
This article was translated from Arabic. Read the Arabic original
Austria Now News, Leipzig: The former mayor of the municipality of Todtmoos in Baden-Württemberg has won her lawsuit seeking equal pay to that of her male predecessor and successor. The Federal Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht) in Leipzig ruled on Thursday, 19 November 2026, that the municipality had discriminated against her on the grounds of her gender under the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG), ordering it to pay 43,500 euros.
Details of the case
Janette Fuchs served as mayor of the municipality located in the southern Black Forest, home to around 2,000 residents, between 2014 and 2022. At the start of her term, the municipal council assigned her to salary grade A14 and only upgraded her to the higher grade A15 halfway through her term, whereas her predecessor and successor—both men—were classified in grade A15 from the beginning.
Fuchs had initially lost the case before the Higher Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg (VGH) before appealing the decision to the Federal Administrative Court.
Why did the court find discrimination?
The court’s Second Senate explained that the case primarily turned on circumstantial evidence. The minutes of the municipal council contained no reasons for the lower grading, while it was established that the two men who held the office before and after her were placed in a higher grade. The court considered this evidence of discrimination that the municipality failed to refute. It also pointed out that only the female mayor was subjected to a quasi-probationary period, as her salary was reviewed mid-term—a procedure not provided for by law.
Under the ruling, Fuchs will receive 36,500 euros in back pay for the salary difference, plus 7,000 euros in compensation, totaling 43,500 euros.
Significance of the ruling
The ruling confirms that paying a woman in a mayoral post less without a documented reason compared to her male predecessors or successors may constitute gender discrimination, and that the authority concerned must prove the existence of objective reasons for the disparity.
Austria Now News, keeping you always updated.
Photo: Federal Administrative Court building in Leipzig, Tim Rademacher, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Sources
Der Spiegel: Todtmoos, Ex-Bürgermeisterin klagt erfolgreich gegen ungleiche Bezahlung, 19.11.2026, Link